Encouraging Signs For The Baseball Hall Of Fame
Friday, January 25, 2019
In addition to Martinez gaining entry into Cooperstown, Mariano Rivera became the first unanimous inductee. While it is simply ludicrous that Babe Ruth, Ty Cobb, Ted Williams, Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, Hank Aaron, et al, ad nauseum, were left off ballots in the past under the pretense that “no one is a first ballot hall of famer,” the fact that this generation of voters may be more concerned with getting it right than in carrying on an absurd tradition is encouraging. Mike Mussina and Roy Halladay were also voted in Tuesday, two nods that may baffle the old guard but are easy calls for those more comfortable with advanced analytics.
By electing Mussina, the BBWAA has essentially signaled that Curt Schilling also belongs in the hall. You can argue that Schilling is not the most stellar human being and that his politics are often reprehensible, but his performance on the field is essentially identical to that of Mussina, if not slightly better. Halladay is a bit more of a stretch in terms of longevity and it is all but certain that his untimely death last season played a part in him getting in on his first year of eligibility, but his career WAR, WAR7, and JAWS are nearly identical to Bob Feller and Juan Marichal, only in a much less pitcher-friendly environment.
The next obvious hurdle for the BBWAA to clear is to elect the third-greatest pitcher of all time and arguably the greatest hitter ever. The two elephants in the room are, of course, Roger Clemens and Barry Bonds. Each has seen their vote percentage creep up over the past seven years, Clemens from 37.6% in 2013 to 59.5% this year and Bonds from 36.2% in 2013 to 59.1% on this last ballot. With just three more chances, it will be interesting to see if these tainted titans of the game can muster the additional 16% or so they need for induction.
On the old timers committee, it may be wishful thinking, but a rule change mandating that no candidates can be considered if they never accumulated, say, 50% of the BBWAA vote would be a step in the right direction. It could be called the Harold Baines Rule.
In 2020, Derek Jeter is likely the only first-time candidate who will get in, perhaps unanimously since his fellow Yankee core four guy Mo set the precedent. That should set the stage for cleaning up some of the backlog, like Schilling, Clemens, and Bonds. In the meantime, congratulations to Edgar, Moose, Mo, and Doc. You are Hall of Famers.
Related Articles
- The Seattle Mariners and Good Problems to Have
- The Seattle Mariners Right Field Platoon: Both Productive and Economical
- The Seattle Mariners Will Be Better Than You Think in 2016
- The Mariners Will Get Better Dee At Second Base
- The 2017 Ex-Seattle Mariners All-Playoff Team
- Seattle Mariners Games are Quick for a Reason
- Seattle Mariners That Should Be In The Baseball Hall Of Fame After Ken Griffey Jr.
- Seattle Mariners – Marco Gonzales And The Roller Coaster Of Emotion
- The State of the Farm System: The Seattle Mariners Organizational Depth
- The State Of The Seattle Mariners’ Farm System
- Where Did the Seattle Mariners Go Wrong?
- Why All Oregonians Should Get Behind the Seattle Mariners!
- Will the Second Half Be Any Different for the Seattle Mariners?
- What Might a 2016 Seattle Mariners Roster Look Like?
- What is the Price of One More Win for the Seattle Mariners?
- The Status Quo Is No Mo’: Seattle Mariners Offseason Update, Part One
- The Two 2015 Free Agents That Can Turn The Mariners (Back?) Into A Contender
Follow us on Pinterest Google + Facebook Twitter See It Read It