Seattle Seahawks In Search Of Toughness
Wednesday, January 27, 2016
Everyone knew the Seahawks were going to face challenges keeping together their talented group from 2012 and 2013. Departures were expected and necessary to hold onto the core players. There are very few decisions Schneider made about who to let go that have come back to bite him.
Consider, though, the aggregate impact of some of these players who moved on: Red Bryant, Tony McDaniel, Alan Branch, Breno Giacomini, James Carpenter, Max Unger, Brandon Browner, Chris Maragos, Golden Tate, Zach Miller, Jeron Johnson, Chris Clemons, Clinton McDonald.
Each of those players was replaced by someone who arguably is less physical. That does not mean it was a downgrade. Would anyone rather have Clemons than Cliff Avril, or Bryant instead of Michael Bennett? Again, this is not about whether the front office made the proper talent evaluation. It is about whether this team has lost too much of its nasty edge of intimidation.
Bryant was a one-trick pony, and left the team largely without a pass rush on one side of the field, but there was not a single offensive line in football that could blow the Seahawks off the ball.
Similarly, Giacomini and Carpenter have serious flaws, but their combination of aggression and brute strength helped the Seahawks line run successfully against eight-man fronts and defenses as physical as the 49ers at their peak.
This Seahawks team struggled at times to win the line of scrimmage. It was especially evident on offense, but the defensive line lacked a physically dominant player. Bennett and Avril are master technicians, but both are undersized.
Toughness does not need to just come from the starters on the offensive and defensive lines. Tate was as physical as any receiver in football. Miller was tough as nails at tight end. Browner is the most badass cornerback in football, even with his flaws. Maragos and Johnson were assassins on special teams. As productive as Jordan Hill was last year, he does not approach the physical style of McDonald as a backup lineman.
None of this is to say the Seahawks lack tough players. They have a ton of them. It simply means a team that used to win some games just walking off the bus, has lost that overwhelming edge of physical intimidation.
Recipe for Tough
The good news is that adding physical players is a lot easier than adding talented players. Guys like Browner, Bryant, McDaniel, and Giacomini were available because they were incomplete. Even Kam Chancellor slide to the fifth round because of concerns about his ability to handle the finer points of the safety position.
Physical intimidation used to be an important part of the Seahawks talent evaluation when Pete Carroll and Schneider first arrived. That seems to have morphed into a search for grit, which is another form of toughness defined more by mental determination. They may have oversteered there. The most determined undersized player will still lose a lot of battles against a more physically dominant one.
When you look at Kawann Short and Star Lotulelei in Carolina, or Aaron Donald and Michael Brockers in St. Louis, you see physically dominant duos who made life miserable for Seattle. Three of those players were first round picks. Short was a second round pick. In fact, Carolina drafted Lotulelei and Short back-to-back in 2013 with their first and second picks. The 49ers used a similar formula when they doubled up on badass offensive lineman Mike Iupati and Anthony Davis with their first two picks in 2010.
The best way to infuse your team with toughness is to invest your most precious draft choices in your lines. It is not gluttonous to pick two defensive tackles or two interior lineman with your first two picks. Create a pile.
The closest the Seahawks have come to doing that was in 2011 when they selected Carpenter in the first round and John Moffitt with their second pick (which was in the third round). It did not work out exactly as planned, but Carpenter did start for a number of years and was a road grader in the run game.
This upcoming draft is the best chance Seattle has had in years to stock up on both sides of the line. The Seahawks have a 1st-round pick, along with a pick in the 2nd-round, and two picks in the 3rd-round. Invest them all in the DL and OL and do not look back.
Consider Current Free Agent Toughness
Some of the Seahawks toughest players are currently in purgatory. Nobody on the team is tougher than J.R. Sweezy. Ask anyone in that locker room. Bruce Irvin is a Pittsburgh Steelers-style linebacker with unmatched physical talent. Marshawn Lynch is likely retiring. Brandon Mebane and Ahtyba Rubin are both free agents. Kam Chancellor could find himself playing elsewhere if the two sides cannot find an amicable way to address his contract concerns. Will Tukuafu is a free agent.
Schneider has to consider physical intimidation and toughness when making his decisions on these players during the offseason. Some of that evaluation may even push some of these players out the door. Chancellor, for example, had one of his least intimidating seasons to date. Perhaps it is time to sell high there and get another draft pick and cap space.
Irvin and Sweezy are two players I would work hard to keep specifically because of the toughness they bring combined with their above average productivity. Are there better players at their position? Of course. Are their tougher players at their positions? Not many.
Seattle took a step back this year in being able to physically dominate the line of scrimmage. The NFC Championship was just the latest example. Schneider has done a great job retaining the core group of young talent, and has the ammunition this offseason to surround them with more badasses to help them return to their rightful place atop the NFL.
Related Slideshow: 15 Biggest Sports Stories of 2015
Seattle Seahawks Fall in Super Bowl
The New England Patriots battled through a nailbiter of a match to win Super Bowl XLIX, which ended in a physical altercation between several players.
Tom Brady led the New England Patriots to the 28-24 victory over the Seattle Seahawks at the University of Phoenix stadium in Glendale, Az. The Seahawks defense intercepted two of quarterback Brady's fully inflated passes, but it would be a New England interception in the final minute of the game that would seal the victory for the Patriots.
The 10 Dumbest Coaching Decisions in NFL History
It's always entertaining when NFL head coaches call what they think is a really good play or a really smart decision and then that decision goes completely wrong. Unless it's your team, then it's terrible.
GoLocalPDX took at look at the 10 dumbest coaching decisions in NFL history.
Alex Morgan is Gone and Portland Thorns Fans are to Blame
The face of U.S. women’s soccer, the cover girl of EA Sports FIFA 16, and one of the most recognizable athletes in all of sports, Alex Morgan, is no longer with the Portland Thorns, and it’s all your fault. Because of your relentless support and record-setting attendance, Portland was able to give in to the request of its most recognizable player, sacrificing star power in favor of gathering more talent and potential to make the Thorns a better team. Much better.
Bring the Arizona Coyotes to Portland
Let’s face it. You are a billionaire and while you don’t like to lose money, you own the Trail Blazers and the Seahawks for the fun of it and the thrill of competition.
You’ve obviously succeeded with the Seahawks (though I still don’t care).
And while your 25-year track record with the Trail Blazers is much more middling, the fact that the Trail Blazers remain in Portland owes much to you. In other words, your sports legacy in Seattle is secure in Seattle and probably intact in Portland, save another “Jail Blazers” stretch.
But if you want to cement your legacy in Portland – and have a blast doing it – bring the Coyotes here.
Oregon’s Football Uniforms No Longer a Joke
It didn’t happen overnight, and it didn’t happen solely because, but Oregon’s uniform revolution kick-started a metamorphosis of previously ugly ducklings into a sports nation of flourishing fowl. The Ducks of today are not the Ducks of 20 years ago, and the punchline they were due to the innovative route they chose to take has become the road more travelled for everyone else trying to catch up. They’re winning at an unprecedented rate, generating revenue at an unprecedented level, and attracting attention from prospects from unprecedented regions of the country. It isn’t and accident and it isn’t a joke anymore.
It appears the Ducks are the ones laughing now.
Marcus Mariota Selected #2 Overall to Tennessee
With the number two pick in the 2015 NFL Draft the Tennessee Titans selected Marcus Mariota.
While at Oregon he was the perfect role model. He was never seen doing anything he wasn’t supposed to do. He even made weekly visits to the Boys and Girls Club located in Eugene, Oregon. The only hiccup on his record was when he got a speeding ticket during the season. Yet, he paid it off immediately and accepted that he was in the wrong. This is something that Duck fans desperately needed to see after witnessing Jeremiah Masoli, Cliff Harris and Colt Lyerla not live up to their full potential because of poor decisions made off the field. To many Duck fans this is what made Mariota so special.
Jerome Kersey Passes Away at 52
Trail Blazers great Jerome Kersey died in Portland, Wednesday. He was 52.
A medical examiner's report released found that Kersey suffered a pulmonary thromboembolism when a blood clot from his calf dislodged from his calf and plugged in his lung.
Brandon Roy’s Life After Basketball
Due to a number of knee ailments that dated back to his college days Roy was forced to retire from the NBA at the age of 28. It was later discovered that Roy suffered from degenerative knees, an ongoing issue that would provide additional problems in the future if he were to continue with his NBA career. Roy made the tough decision to call it a career after the 2012-2013 season.
Since his retirement from the NBA Roy has found another way to stay involved with the game that has brought him plenty of success.
Oregon Ducks Football Falls in National Championship Game
The first ever College Football Playoff National Championship Trophy will not be coming back to Oregon.
Kurt Helfrich’s Oregon Ducks could not hold off the gritty offense of Cardale Jones and the Ohio State Buckeyes, dropping 42-20.
Will Marijuana Use Cost the Ducks the National Championship?
Multiple reports surfaced late Friday that freshman Darren Carrington would be ineligible for Monday’s national championship against Ohio State for failing a random drug test, supposedly registering a positive for marijuana.
- Seattle Seahawks To Russell Wilson: Here’s To Four More Years
- Seattle Seahawks Shut Out Chicago Bears for First Win of the Season
- Seattle Seahawks Season Review And Awards - What Lies Ahead In 2016
- Seattle Seahawks-The Titantic Wake of Scott McCloughan
- Seattle Seahawks: 2015 Final Act
- Seattle Seahawks: Looming Showdown With Arizona Will Make Or Break Their Season
- Seattle Seahawks: Keys To Victory And A Brutally Cold Playoff History
- Seattle Seahawks Salary Cap
- Seattle Seahawks Marshawn Lynch Finally Receives $75k Media Fine
- Seattle Seahawks Back-up Defense Showcase Talent in Preseason Games
- Seattle Seahawks are a Team in Transition
- Seattle Seahawks Draftland: Where the First Round Doesn’t Matter
- Seattle Seahawks Face Criticism Over Draft Pick
- Seattle Seahawks Loss Only Makes Them More Likable—It’s An Unwritten Rule In Sports
- Seattle Seahawks Lose Game In Overtime to Cincinnati Bengals
- Seattle Seahawks: Opportunity – And Brutally Cold Weather Await In Minnesota
- Spotted In Portland: Seattle Seahawks’ Richard Sherman
- Three Things The Seattle Seahawks Are Doing Wrong
- The Seattle Seahawks’ Road to Super Bowl 50
- The Seattle Seahawks’ Newest Solution to an Old Problem
- Training Camp is a Must Go for Seattle Seahawks Fans
- WATCH: Seahawks’ Kam Chancellor Forces Game-Saving Fumble
- Why Supporting the Seahawks Out of Solidarity is Wrong
- Which Seattle Seahawks Players Belong On The Team’s Mount Rushmore?
- The Seattle Seahawks Road to a Rematch
- The Seattle Seahawks Look at their Defensive Line Options
- The Grudge Match: Seattle Seahawks at Green Bay Packers
- Ten Facts You Should Know About the Seattle Seahawks and Carolina Panthers
- The Leading Contenders to Replace the Seahawks’ Pro Bowl-Sized Hole
- The New NFL Siberia: Playing Guard for the Seattle Seahawks
- The Seattle Seahawks Are Back In Command
- The Seahawks Don’t Need an NFL Wild Card
- Seattle Seahawks - The Winter of Our Discontent
- Seahawks Vs. Packers: An Improbable Win
- He Said / She Said: Seattle Seahawks at Carolina Panthers
- He Said / She Said: Seattle Seahawks at Baltimore Ravens
- He Said / She Said: Chicago Bears at Seattle Seahawks
- He Said / She Said: Seattle Seahawks at Cincinnati Bengals
- He Said / She Said: Seattle Seahawks at Minnesota Vikings
- He Said / She Said: Seattle Seahawks vs. Arizona Cardinals
- He Said / She Said: Carolina Panthers at Seattle Seahawks
- Half of Seventeen is Nine: A Look at the Seattle Seahawks Playoff Odds
- Carolina Panthers Vs. Seahawks: What to Watch For
- Game Preview: Seattle Seahawks vs. Detroit Lions
- Game Review: Seattle Seahawks vs. Detroit Lions
- Grand Central’s 12th Man Loaf Celebrates Seahawks’ Super Bowl Appearance
- Game Review: Seattle Seahawks vs. Green Bay Packers
- He Said / She Said: Seattle Seahawks vs. Cleveland Browns
- He Said / She Said: Seattle Seahawks vs. Pittsburgh Steelers
- Only One Thing Can Stop a Seattle Seahawks Dynasty in 2015
- On the Bright Side… Thoughts Through Week 6 About the Seahawks
- Player Profile: Seattle Seahawks WR Rookie Tyler Lockett
- Red Robin Offering Free Burgers to Seattle Seahawks Fans
- Seahawks Get Beat in Overtime - See How the Rest of the NFL Performed
- NFC Playoff Picture: Seattle Seahawks Are Officially Back In The Hunt
- New Seahawks TE Jimmy Graham Clicking with Russell Wilson
- He Said / She Said: Seattle Seahawks’ Second-Half Outlook
- He Said / She Said: Seattle Seahawks vs. San Francisco 49ers
- He Said / She’s Depressed: Seattle Seahawks Season Wrap-Up
- Here We Go Again: Green Bay Packers Visit Seattle Seahawks
- New England Patriots Defeat Seattle Seahawks 28-24 in Super Bowl XLIX
- Kam Chancellor Needs to Honor His Contract with the Seattle Seahawks
- 3 Things to Watch in the Seattle Seahawks’ 1st Preseason Game